Using qualifying adjectives to take the judge role

Quote from Razor on February 4, 2022, 9:49 pm

I think using qualifying adjectives automatically puts you in the judge role.

For example when someone sends you an email:

Neutral: "Thank you for your email"

Judge: "Thank you for your clear email"

Or when someone shows you their new shoes:

Neutral: "Nice shoes!"

Judge: "You've picked the right shoes! You've got a good taste"

Do you think it could be that easy?