Are you looking for an unbiased Blinkist review?
Maybe you are wondering whether or not you should sign up for the Blinkist service.
Or maybe you are just curious and want to look at an unbiased Blikist review (you know, one that does not propose you with an affiliate link in the end).
Well, you have come to the right page.
This is a Review of Blinkist from someone who is a nut about knowledge acquisition and does not make money out of affiliate services.
- Blinkist Review by a Compulsive Reader
- Blinkist Pros
- Blinkist Cons
- Blinkist Review: The Final Verdict
Hence, a book summary service should be perfect, right?
Well, yes and no.
Books should add value to your life.
Adding books like players add notches under their belts won’t make you any better and won’t budge you of a single centimeter forward.
Therefore, my philosophy being of doing anything that moves you forward, I don’t buying into the braggart idea of of “reading X books in X time”.
And that’s exactly one of Blinkist’ value propositions when they ask:
Ever read read four books in a day?
However, that being said, there are some good cases for book summaries.
So let’s start with the Blinkist review:
Here are the advantages of using Blinkist:
1. Saves Time on Poor Books
Short waste of time is better than big waste of time
Let’s be frank, not all books are worth your time.
Some might even be great books, but they don’t fit your goals, personality, or lifestyle.
And some might be great authors or great people, but they’re just putting out content to monetize their name-brand.
In these cases, a summary saves you time (and money)
2. Good Books Get 80% Value in 20% Space
Pareto says yes in his Blinkist review
Some books -but not all, read the cons!- can be easily summarized and you can get most of the value in a quarter of the time (and cost).
One example could be The 10X Rule.
Even with some great books you can get 80% in 20%, and I think of the 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership.
3. Some Summaries Are Good
There’s good stuff on Blinkist
I purposefully tried some of my favorite books. I picked The Paradox of Choice, which makes it in the Top 10 of my Best Self-Help Books.
And they did a rather good job (albeit the very important steps on how to go from maximer to satisficers were missing).
4. Captivating Format
It’s hip to be Blink!
It’s no mystery that one of Blinkist’s secrets to success is the format.
The marketing, the sleek interface, the quotes… The bite-sized pages that make us feel smart :).
That’s also the danger in a way: reading shouldn’t only be pleasure for pleasure sake. It should serve your advancement.
And these are the cons based on my Blinkist review:
1. Great Books Lose 90% of Value
Don’t skimp on greatness!
The really good books, with lots of content and lots of wisdom are difficult to summarize. For anyone.
And I don’t think Blinkist does a good enough job with the books I tested.
I think of The Art of Seduction, which the Blink summary pretty much butchered.
2. Some Bad Summaries
How far can you trust Blinkists’ employees?
I have seen a few mistakes and some bad summaries on Blinkist.
For example In the Blink Mindset The Psychology of Success, the Blinkist summary reads:
“it’s not necessary to give up a fixed mindset altogether and it’s usually enough to adopt the growth perspective in certain situation”.
That’s not something Dweck ever said and that’s not the message of the book at all.
And you SHOULD give up a fixed mindset altogether.
Do yourself a favor instead and read how to develop a growth mindset.
3. No Rankings: False Objectivity
Which one should I pick of these thousands here?
Services like Blinkist don’t -and possibly can’t because of the agreements they sign- rank their summaries.
They try to be always positive and objective. But I don’t think that’s helpful to readers.
One because it gives an appearance of objectivity while instead every summary, by definition, is a personal work.
And two because ranking are helpful to prioritize.
That’s why I like following a few readers I trust. I know they know their stuff and I can trust them on what I should and should not read.
4. Impartial Book Summaries
What’s not good with the book? What could be done better?
Blinkist probably has publishers deals to sell summaries.
And I don’t think they are allowed either personal opinions or negative opinions. Some might like it, but it’s not my cup of tea. I like very much enjoy reading the reviewer’s opinion. That helps me assess both the quality of the summary and, indirectly, how knowledgeable the review is.
For example, in the otherwise wonderful book The 48 Laws of Power, I put as a con that the book only sees relationships as battles to win.
I feel that’s an important point to make as seeing relationships as power struggles makes you a power addict. But that’s not something you would read on a Blinkist summary.
5. Books In Silos: No Contrasting Theories
Does the literature and research confirm the author’s opinions?
Blikist summaries look at books as silos.
There’s rarely a mention to what other authors say and rarely they introduce contrasting theories.
But mentioning contrasting theories is important for readers to make sense of a subject.
For example, if you read my summary of How to Win Friends I tell you it’s a must read book. But I also tell you that people who are too passive should work on their assertiveness before making it all about others. And I point the readers to other interpersonal skills books such as Difficult Conversations and Eliminating Passive Aggressiveness.
To add the most value to the readers I try to do two things (example below):
- In blue ink I highlight my own comments
- I present contrasting theories, helping the reader make sense of a topic
Blinkist Silos Failure Example
Here’s a book I recently tested on Blinkist: The China Study.
The China Study is considered the vegetarian bible. So far so good. However, it makes huge claims. Such as that mean drastically increase your chances of cancer.
The China Study has been severely criticized for being unscientific an for bending the data to fit its agenda.
Any summary not mentioning that kind of criticism is doing a disservice, in my opinion. And Blinkist promotes The China Study as it was going to save your life.
6. Fun-Fact Attitude
It feels to me like Blinkinst is about “making reading fun”. Which is OK.
But non sci-fi reading can also be a serious endeavor to gather knowledge that move us forward. And I find the fun-fact attitude does not help.
Here is an example:
“But did you know that” is a typical “fun fact” attitude. I’m personally not interested in fun facts. I want facts, not fun facts.
And I want to know how they can help me move forward.
I want critical observation of wisdom, information, science and research. And I don’t always find it in Blinkist.
To summaries this Blinkist review: yes or no?
I can’t answer for you, but I can tell you what I’m doing. And I am not using it.
If you are money-conscious, there is enough good free summaries out there.
And there’s enough information to help you wade through the books worth reading and the ones not worth reading.
And if you are knowledge conscious, you want the full version of the books worth reading.
There’s my point of view as of today. I might change my mind, and I’ll make sure to update this post.
If you disagree, I respect your opinion and I would be curious to hear your own experience.
And if this post was helpful and you want to give Blinkist a try, this is an affiliate link for you.